Objective To evaluate whether the paper titled “Application of tumor type M2 pyruvate kinase in the diagnosis of lung cancer” met the standards set in the STARD statement. Methods Based on each of the 25 items of STAndards for the Reporting of Diagnostic accuracy studies (STARD statement), the paper titled “Application of tumor type M2 pyruvate kinase in the diagnosis of lung cancer” was checked and evaluated. Results In the paper titled “Application of tumor type M2 pyruvate kinase in the diagnosis of lung cancer”, the reporting of 1 item of the STARD statement was adequately standardized, 7 items were relatively standardized, 5 items were inadequately standardized, 2 items were not standardized, and the other 10 were not reported. Conclusion Generally speaking, the reporting of diagnostic accuracy studies has not been standardized adequately in China. The methodological quality and applicability of diagnostic accuracy studies should be improved.
【摘要】 目的 探討高血壓危象評估和處理原則及對高血壓危象急診處理的指導意義。 方法 依據高血壓危象評估和處理原則對2008年1月-2009年12月期間收治的160例高血壓危象患者進行診斷和治療。結果 160例高血壓危象患者中,高血壓急癥134例,高血壓亞急癥26例。高血壓急癥中,以心腦血管病變為主,包括腦卒中、急性冠脈綜合征和急性左側心力衰竭。依據高血壓危象評估和處理原則進行急診處理,能夠對高血壓危象進行準確評估和有效處理,減少診治失誤,降低死亡率并改善預后。結論 有關高血壓危象的評估和處理原則能夠指導高血壓危象的急診處理,取得良好的預后。【Abstract】 Objective To investigate the principles of evaluation and management of hypertensive crises in order to guide emergency clinical practice for better managements and prognosis. Methods One hundred and sixty patients with hypertensive crises admitted to our department from January 2008 to December 2009 had been diagnosed and treated. Results There were 134 patients with hypertensive emergencies (HE) and 26 patients with hypertensive urgencies(HU)in accordance with those principle. Cardiocerebralvascular diseases were the main symptom of HE including stroke, acute coronary syndrome and acute left ventricular failure. According to those principles,the emergency management was carried out, accuracy evaluation and effective management of hypertensive crises could reduce wrong diagnosis and treatment,decrease mortality and improve prognosis. Conclusion The principle of evaluation and management of hypertensive crises could guide the emergency management of hypertensive crises and obtain better prognosis．
ObjectivesTo provide a reference for the evaluation procedures of genetic testing technology applicable to China by combining the existing evaluation frameworks and procedures for genetic testing techniques globally, and also put forward design suggestions for the construction of evaluation procedures in China.MethodsThe literature research method was primarily used to summarize different evaluation progress, as well as put forward design suggestions.ResultsAt present, numerous developed countries have organized genetic testing technology evaluation projects. The various evaluation frameworks developed were based on the ACCE or HTA framework. The evaluation and decision-making procedures were similar in general, including topic selection, evaluation implementation, results reporting and making recommendations. However, there still remained difficulties such as limited evidence and uncertainty in decision-making.ConclusionsTo establish the procedures of genetic testing technology applicable in China, the following specific procedures are recommended: selecting target genetic testing technology topics; analyzing necessity and feasibility of target testing technology evaluation; evaluating and reviewing the evidence; applying results and decision-making transformation; developing regular review and revision mechanisms.
The purpose of this paper is to discuss the evaluation standard of rationality of medical examination from different perspectives, so as to provide theoretical evidence for medical department to establish the evaluation standard of the rationality of medical examination. By researching the relevant literature in the field of rational medical examination and combing the existing research results, this paper discusses the evaluation criteria of the rationality of medical examination from four dimensions: technology, ethics, law, and health economy. The following four suggestions are proposed for the current status of medical examination: construct clinical pathway management to avoid excessive medical examination; establish the internal supervision and evaluation mechanism to improve the professional quality of medical staff; improve medical examination-related policies, laws, and regulations, carry out specialized legislation; apply diagnosis-related group payment method, control the cost of medical examination.
Objective To analyze the methodological quality of clinical practice guideline mentioned “evidence-based” in China. Methods We selected clinical guidelines developed based on evidence issued by the Chinese Medical Association in 2010-2012, and meanwhile, we conducted additional search for guidelines on clinical major diseases. Then, we selected literature according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria and evaluated the included guidelines according to 8 items relevant to methodological rigor which were selected from the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II). If the guidelines comply with the item, we recorded 1 point, otherwise 0 point. Results a) Among twenty-two included guidelines, 13 were originated and 9 were updated once every 3 to 5 years. b) Diseases covered stroke, diabetes, chronic hepatitis B, hypertension, pediatric nutrition, etc. c) The number of guideline references were 10 to 218, of which, nine guidelines cited 24 Cochrane systematic reviews (CDSRs), accounted for 2.62% (24/916). Among them, the acute ischemic stroke guideline cited the most (7 CDSRs). d) The number of experts involved in guidelines development was 2 to 95 and guidelines pages were 4 to 150. e) The guidelines’ quality generally scored 4 to 7, most of which described the process of guidelines development. The grades of recommendation were consistent with the levels of evidence. But most of the included guidelines did not clearly described literature research methods, peer reviewer, and update procedures. Conclusion There is a growing trend that clinical guidelines are developed based on evidence in China. However, the quality of reporting and the methodological rigor of guidelines need further improvement. The citation rates of Cochrane systematic reviews in these guidelines were relatively low. We suggest that guideline recommendations should be consistent with the levels of evidence and adapt to local conditions, and relevant support policies for guideline implementation in practice. In future, attention should be paid to the aspects of guideline development methods, reporting standard, guideline accessibility, and standard training for relevant personnel.
ObjectiveTo establish a rat model of diabetic microangiopathopathy and simulate the biochemical and pathological changes of diabetic retinal and renal microangiopathopathy. MethodsForty healthy male Sprague-Dawley rats were randomly divided into blank group and model group (10 and 30 rats, respectively). After the rats in blank group and model group were fed ordinary diet and high-fat and high-sugar diet for 5 weeks, respectively, the rats in model group were injected with 1% streptozotocin (STZ) through the abdominal cavity at the dose of 35 mg/kg to establish a type 2 diabetes model. After modeling, the rats were continuously fed until the 10th week (4 weeks after modeling), the general conditions of the rats were observed, and samples were collected for follow-up experiments. Serum creatinine (CREA), triglyceride (TG), total cholesterol (TC), high density lipoprotein (HDL-C), low density lipoprotein (LDL-C), microalbuminuria, urinary creatinine (UCr) and urine sugar were detected. Calculate the kidney index and microalbumin/urinary creatinine ratio (UACR). Optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) was used to observe the vascular changes and non-perfusion area of retinal superficial capillary plexus. The morphological and structural changes of kidney and retina were observed by hematoxylin-eosin and periodate Scheff staining. The expression of nerve fibers and nucleus of Müller cells in rat retina was observed by immunofluorescence staining. Ultrastructural results of retina were observed by transmission electron microscope. Independent sample t test was used for comparison between groups. ResultsFour weeks after modeling, compared with blank group, the body weight of rats in model group was significantly decreased, and random glucose was significantly increased, with statistical significance (t=5.755, －51.291; P＜0.05). Renal index, urinary glucose and UACR were significantly increased, while UCr was significantly decreased, with statistical significance (t=10.878, 137.273, 3.482, －6.110; P＜0.05). CREA decreased, TG, TC, HDL-C, LDL-C increased, and the differences were statistically significant (t=－28.012, 33.018, 118.018, 13.585, 16.480; P＜0.05). OCTA examination showed that there was no perfusion area of shallow retinal capillaries. The optical microscope showed that the inner boundary membrane of retina in model group was swollen and thickened, the surface was uneven, the inner and outer nuclear layer cells were disordered and the density decreased. Glomerular congestion was accompanied by cortical tubular epithelial swelling, widening of the mesangial area, and thickening of the basement membrane. The results of immunostaining showed that the inner and outer plexiform layers of the retina showed lamellar strong green fluorescence expression, and the inner and outer nuclear layers showed scattered dot green fluorescence expression. Transmission electron microscopy showed that the basal membrane of retinal microvessels in model group was slightly thickened, vascular endothelial cells edema, endothelial nucleus and perinucleus contraction, nuclear membrane contraction, mild mitochondrial swelling, vacuolation. ConclusionHigh-glucose and high-fat feeding plus a single intraperitoneal injection of STZ 35 mg/kg can successfully establish a microangiopathic model of type 2 diabetes.
Objective To investigate the correlation between the initial arterial blood lactic acid and Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) Ⅱ score in trauma patients and its value in prognosis. Methods From August 1st 2015 to July 31st 2016, the clinical data of trauma patients treated in Department of Emergency were analyzed retrospectively. All patients were divided into survival group and death group by observing 28-day prognosis. We compared the relationship between the initial blood lactate level and APACHEⅡ score, and analyzed the relationship between the above indexes and the prognosis of the patients. Results A total of 743 patients were enrolled, with692 in survival group and 51 in death group.The APACHEⅡ score and initial blood lactate level in the survival group [(9.93±4.62) points, (2.02±1.44) mmol/L] were significantly lower than those in the death group [(22.84±7.26) points, (4.60±3.69) mmol/L] with significant differences (t=18.20, 9.77; P<0.01). The APACHEⅡ score and the mortality rate of patients with lactic acid level >4 mmol/L were significantly higher than those of patients with lactic acid of 2-4 mmol/L and <2 mmol/L; the differences were significant (P<0.05). The blood lactate and mortality in patients with APACHEⅡ score >20 were significantly higher than those in the patients with ≤10 and 11-20; the differences were significant (P<0.05). There was a significant positive correlation between initial blood lactate level and APACHEⅡ score (r=0.426, P<0.01). Conclusions The initial blood lactate level and APACHEⅡ score of trauma patients are correlated with the severity of injury and mortality. Both of the increase of initial blood lactic acid level and APACHEⅡ score suggest the risk of death in trauma patients.
This paper analyzed the four aspects of the medical consortium both in China and abroad, including evaluation of object, theoretical basis and model, content and method, and provided reference for construction and development of medical consortium evaluation in China.
Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has some unique advantages in the prevention and treatment of cancer. Due to different ideas and mechanism of between TCM and biomedicine in the prevention and treatment of cancer, the clinial effect evaluation approches of biomedicine could not be used as a beneficial method to scientifically evaluate the effects of TCM. From three angles, this article analyzes the key issues regardsing the evaluation methods of TCM as an adjuvant therapy of cancer. It draws lessons from the idea of quality-adjusted survival (QAS), proposes Two-in-One (TIO) method to evaluate the effects of TCM as adjuvant therapy of cancer, which reflects the combined value of the individual patient dynamic information and provides methodological support for the effect evaluation of TCM.
Objective To investigate the research base and current understanding of the mechanism of ischemia-reperfusion injury (IR) to intrahepatic cholangiocytes after l iver transplantation, so as to identify the key points of the mechanism and provide references for cl inical practice. Methods We searched PubMed (1970 to 2007) and CBM(1979 to 2007). Qual ity assessment and data collection were performed by two reviewers independently. Since the baseline supplied and the measure were very different, we decided to provide a descriptive summary only. Results The earliest study on liver IR was publ ished in 1970. A total of 65 papers were included. There were 13 on cl inical studies, 35 on basic research studies; and 17 review articles. Most basic studies focus on injury mechanism: ① The physiology of bile ducts and Intrahepatic Bil iary Duct Cells(IBDC); ②the IR caused injury mechanism of IBDC during or after liver transplantation; ③ the basic injury mechanisms include: cold ischemia, warm ischemia, reperfusion, injury of bile and bile salts. Most clinical studies focused on preventive measures, including surgical and non-surgical approaches. Based on the evidence from basic research, changing the composition and perfusion methods of perfusate and protecting the specific blood supply to biliary ducts and cholangiocytes during the operation were important in preventing or reducing such an injury. Conclusion ① The heterogeneity of morphology, function, status and the special blood supply in large and small IBDC are important material base. ② Our own study indicated that simple IR or H/R was able to change the expression of MHC, MIC, DR4, DR5 and other adhesion molecules. ③ Compared to hepatic cells, hIBDC can’ t resist cold ischemia and even worse in tolerating reperfusion injury. ④ Hydrophobic bile salts will could increase the harm to bile ducts during organ preservation. ⑤ Due to the low quantity and limited quantities of clinical researches, the power of evidence was low. The evaluation indexes and baseline conditions are not unified. So the conclusions are for reference only.