Objective Evidence-based medicine was used to make an individualized treatment plan for newly diagnosed prostatic hyperplasia in an elderly patient. Methods After clinical problems were discovered, evidence was collected from CBM, CNKI, The Cochrane Library, PubMed, EMBASE, ScienceDirect, Springer, and ProQuest databases according to our predefined search strategy. The search was done through 2008. The internal and external validity of the evidence was assessed. The evidence, combined with the patient value, was applied to the patient. Results A total of 39 systematic reviews involving 137 randomized controlled trials were identified. A rational treatment plan was made upon a critical evaluation of the data. After one year follow-up, the treatment protocol was proven correct. Conclusion The treatment efficacy in newly diagnosed prostatic hyperplasia in the elderly has been improved by determining an individualized treatment protocol according to evidence-based methods.
Objective To formulate an evidence-based treatment plan for a child patient with Asymptomatic Wolff-Parkinson-White (WPW) Syndrome. Methods Based on the clinical problems whether the patients with asymptomatic WPW syndrome need prevent catheter ablation or not, we used “asymptomatic WPW syndrome” as the keywords and searched The Cochrane Library (Issue 3, 2007), MEDLINE (1981 to 2007), ACP Journal Club (1991 to 2007), BMJ Clinical Evidence (1999 to 2007) and NGC (1998 to 2007) for systematic reviews, randomized controlled trials (RCTs), controlled clinical trials and treatment guidelines. The methodological quality of the included studies was assessed to identify the current best evidence. Results Two RCTs were retrieved in MEDLINE. The results showed arrhythmic events increased significantly in the high-risk control group than those in the ablation group, and in the patients with multi-pathways than those with only one pathway. Based on the current evidence, integrated with clinical expertise and the patients’ values, the patients underwent electrophysiologic test and the result showed the dominance pathway in the right side and the concealed accessory pathway in the left side. Then prevent catheter ablation was performed, and no cardiovascular complications occurred in the following 12 months, which confirmed that the plan was proved optimal. Conclusion The findings of this study should reassure physicians and parents alike that in the children with the WPW syndrome who are at high risk for arrhythmias, ablation is an appropriate option.
Objective The objective of this study is to find individualized, evidence-based treatment for a patientwith extensive small cell lung cancer, malignant pleural effusion, and liver metastasis.Methods According to the PICO (patient intervention comparison outcome) principle, evidence was collected and critically assessed. The patient’s preference was also taken into consideration in the decision making process. Results We included 10 randomized controlled trials, 13 systematic reviews and meta-analyses, and three clinical guidelines. The evidence indicated that chemotherapeutic treatment prolongs survival in patients with extensive small cell lung cancer and AiDi injections could relieve adverse effects caused by chemotherapy or radiotherapy. Cisplatin and etoposide are considered major standard cytotoxic drugs for small cell lung cancer. We drained the pleural cavity and infused Bleomycin into the pleural cavity. We also used an EP regimen of chemotherapy after the patient’s condition had improved. This patient survived longer than the average survival time for small cell lung cancer patients and has enjoyed a higher quality of life. Conclusion Chemotherapy is the main medical treatment for patients with extensive small cell lung cancer, backed up by symptomatic treatment and supportive care. Prophylactic cranial irradiation decreases brain metastases incidence and improves survival in complete response small cell lung cancer patients.
Objective To find individualized evidence-based treatments for a patient with lower rectal cancer. Methods Based on the clinical questions raised, evidence was collected and critically assessed. Patient preferences and physician clinical experience were also taken into consideration in the decision-making treatment. Results Twenty-four systematic reviews or meta analyses and 1 clinical guideline were included. The evidence showed that preoperative chemoradio- therapy reduces risk of local recurrence and death from rectal cancer compared to preoperative radiotherapy alone. Preoperative combined chemoradiotherapy, enhanced pathological response and improved local control in the resectable stage II and III rectal cancer. Preoperative chemoradiotherapy reduced the risk of local recurrence as compared with postoperative chemoradiotherapy. Postoperative radiotherapy alone did not improve survival for the patients with resected stage II and stage III rectal cancer, whereas either chemotherapy alone or combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy improved survival in comparison with observation. As compared with conventional radical surgery, total mesorectum excision (TME) resulted in lower postoperative local recurrence rate and higher survival rate. No significant differences in terms of disease-free survival rate, local recurrence rate, mortality, and morbidity were found between laparoscopic and open total mesorectal excision. Conclusion The patients with lower rectal cancer might benefit from preoperative chemoradiotherapy, postoperative chemotherapy, and chemoradiotherapy. TME is the standard rectal cancer surgery. However, long-term prognostic benefits need to be confirmed by further follow-up.
Objective To explore the methods of evidence-based individualized treatment for a patient with oral pemphigus. Methods According to chnical problems, we searched The Coehrane Library （Issue 1,2005 ） , MEDLINE （1966 -Jan. 2005 ）, SUMSEAR.CH （Jan. 2005 ）, TRIPDATABASE （1997 - 2005 ）, CMCC （1994 - 2004 ）and handsearched four Chinease journals （starting pubhcation -2004）. Results No Systematic review was found. Six randomised controlled trials, two reviews of high quality and one guidehne were identified. We found that corticosteroid was the firsthne medicine in the treatment of pemphigus. However, corticosteroid at higher dose did not work more effectively than that at lower dose. Corticosteroid at middle-dose was preferred in treating oral pemphigus. Additionally, corticosteroid combined with immunosuppressants led to lower mortality. Among them, cyclophosphamide and azathioprine were recommended, and methopterin should be avoided. Plasma exchange in combination with corticosteroid at lowor middle-dose should not be recommended in conventional therapy. Chinese traditional treatment combined with Western medicine might work. A treatment with prednisone at the dose of 60 mg/d and in combination with azathioprine 100mg/d was made based on the evaluation of the data available and was proved optimal by 6 months following-up. Conclusions The therapeutic effect of pemphigus has been improved by evidence-based treatment.
Objective To make an individualized treatment plan for newly diagnosed irritable bowel syndrome by means of evidence-based medicine. Methods After clinical problems were put forward, systematic reviews and randomized controlled trials were collected from The Cochrane Library (Issue 3, 2008) and PubMed (1990 to 2008). Treatment protocol was produced by combining the evidence and the values of the patient. Results A total of 114 RCTs and 21 systematic reviews were identified. A rational treatment plan was made upon a serious evaluation of the data to control symptoms and improve the quality of life for the patient. After a sixteen-month follow-up, the plan proved to be optimal. Conclusion The treatment efficacy in diagnosed irritable bowel syndrome has been improved by determining an individualized treatment plan according to evidence-based methods.
Objective We searched and reviewed medical evidence to find the guide of treatment for local advanced nasopharyngeal carcinoma. Methods Firstly, we put forward clinical questions. Secondly, we searched medical evidence from Medline (1985-2002), Embase (1984-2000), Cochrane library (2002.1) and ACP. And then we reviewed the results. The key words we used were "nasopharyngeal carcinoma, chemotherapy and radiotherapy randomized" and "meta analysis or randomized control trial". Results Through searching, we got 17 papers including 1 systematic review and 16 randomized control trials, in which there were 8 prospective randomized phase Ⅲ trials. Most of these trials concluded that combination chemo-radiotherapy were better than radiotherapy alone. We think these results were suitable for our patient’treatment decision. Conclusion To treat our patients,we choosed the method of the mutimodality of squeitial neoadjuvant chemotherapy, concurrent chemo-radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy with the drug doses down-adjusted.
目的 針對近期收治的1例常規治療療效不理想的潰瘍性結腸炎患者,我們進行了證據檢索和評價,以期找到更有效的治療方法.方法 計算機檢索MEDLINE(1978～2004)、CBMdisc(1978～2004)及Cochrane圖書館(2004年第3期),查找 5-氨基水楊酸(5-ASA)灌腸液治療潰瘍性結腸炎及與病情緩解有關的系統評價、臨床隨機對照試驗等,并對所獲證據進行評價.結果 高質量的臨床證據表明,5-ASA灌腸液治療潰瘍性結腸炎及幫助病情緩解均優于口服5-ASA及柳氮磺胺嘧啶局部灌腸治療.據此臨床證據,結合醫生經驗及病人意愿,對該例患者實施5-ASA 1g+生理鹽水100 ml qd,睡前保留灌腸治療.1周后,患者臨床癥狀明顯緩解,腹瀉基本停止,每天解黃色黏液便1～2次.腸鏡復查,炎癥較前明顯減輕.出院后繼續用上述方案維持治療,每周2次.門診隨訪1年,患者未再復發,也無明顯副作用發生.結論 5-ASA灌腸液是控制潰瘍性結腸炎活動期間病情及幫助緩解、減少復發的有效藥物.
Objective To assess the systematic reviews of magnesium sulfate used to treat severe asthma. Methods An electronic search was performed in The Cochrane Library (Issue 2, 2008), ACP Journal Club (1991 to June 2008), MEDLINE (1990 to June 2008), Chinese Journal Full-text Database (1979 to June 2008), Chinese Scientific and Technological Periodical Databases (VIP) (1980 to June 2008), and Chinese Bio-medicine Database (CBM) (1980 to June 2008) to collect systematic reviews of magnesium sulfate treatment for severe asthma. The retrieved systematic reviews were reassessed, and then we adopted the evidence for clinical practice. Results Nine systematic reviews were included, and all of them included 14.1 ± 2.9 items of QUOROM (the quality of reporting of Meta-analyses) on average. In general, the included systematic reviews had comparatively high quality. Evidence illustrated that intravenous infusion of magnesium sulfate could improve pulmonary function and reduce hospital admission without any serious side effects. However, no evidence could verify that patients with asthma can benefit from aerosolized and oral magnesium sulfate. In a specific case with severe asthma, we used magnesium sulfate via intravenous infusion which helped the control of symptoms with no adverse reactions. Conclusion Magnesium sulfate via intravenous infusion can improve pulmonary function and reduce hospital admission rates. Due to its effectiveness, safety, and low cost, it deserves widespread application in patients with severe asthma.
Objective Making an individualized pharmacological treatment plan for a patient of acute respiratory distress syndrome after operation. Methods First, six clinical problems were put forward after assessing the patient’ s health state. Then we searched OVID versions of the ACP Journal Club (1991~2009), CENTRAL (1st Quarter 2009), CDSR (1st Quarter 2009), and MEDLINE (1991~2009) databases. Systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and randomized clinical trials about treatment of acute respiratory distress syndrome were included. The pharmacological treatment plan was made accordingly.Results After evaluation, 13 studies were eligible. The evidence indicated that the restrictive strategy of fluid management, corrected hypoproteinaemia, diuresis, and low-dose corticosteroids given in the early phase could improve oxygenation and prognosis; inhaled nitric oxide, exogenous surfactant supplement, other pharmacological drugs were associated with limited improvement in oxygenation in patients with ARDS but confer no mortality benefit and may cause harm, so we did not recommend their routine use in ARDS patients. The individual treatment plan was made based on the evidence found. After 8 days of treatment, the patient was out the ICU. He recovered and was discharged after 1 month. Conclusions The individual treatment plan, which was made based on high quality evidence and patient’s condition, improved treatment efficacy, shortened the stay in ICU, reduced mortality, and decreased adverse reactions.